Monday, March 14, 2011

Search Engines: Outsourcing Knowledge and the Human Memory

In what year did Thomas Edison invent the phonograph? Before the time of the internet and search engines, the world had to access specific information through libraries, museums, schools and other public locations of knowledge. However; in the new era of high speed internet, people can now access this information within seconds with search engines. Popular search engines such as Google, Bing, Yahoo And other search engines has made it possible to access any source of knowledge that any person desires. People of the 21st century have become so dependent on this quick form of information that people even use the phrase “Google it” whenever people do not know an answer to a question. So why is this a problem? Shouldn’t this form of instant information be praised and not looked down upon? Although instant access to any source of knowledge is something to be amazed about, the problem lies on how obsessive people have become to using the internet for knowledge rather than to immerse themselves in a book.
http://orlandosearchenginemarketing.com/

In Nicholas Carr’s book, The Shallows, he goes into full detail about the troubling issues with addiction to using search engines. Carr discusses the difference between learning from the internet and learning from a book. While reading a book the reader does not just learn little Snapple facts. The reader learns about everything that surrounds the topic of their inquiry.  The new knowledge the reader gains is truly retain in the readers mind. They take time and patience to learn and understand the topic of their choice.
So how does the internet differ from reading books and literature? They both have text and possess the same information as the other. Why should we not embrace the new evolution of attaining information? Whenever you search for an answer through the internet it only take a few seconds. Not only it takes a few seconds, but it goes right to the specific answer the searcher needed to know. There is no time and patience for the new knowledge. There is no work in understanding the surrounding knowledge in the answer. People search, find their answer, and leave away with their Snapple fact. People who use the internet as their substitute for libraries, museums, schools and other public locations of knowledge have no use to learn how to retain information. Instant access to knowledge cannot train the brain to retain knowledge. Learning through the internet does nothing to train the brain to learn and retain knowledge. Dependence on search browsers causes people to lose the ability to retain information because they have no use to retain knowledge. At the same time it would take for somebody to remember a specific answer to a question. People can search for the answer on a search browser. Search browsers is convenient  for finding quick information, but over time people addicted to search browsers become less dependent on their own memory. They become dependent on outsource memory on the information highway.
So what year did Thomas Edison invent the phonograph? The information can be found on the internet, but instead try to find the answer in a book. In a book not only will the answer be revealed, but you will train your mind to retain information and you will be surprised what other information you might find out.
Carr, Nicholas. The Shallows. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 2010. Print.
Chris Childs

4 comments:

  1. I disagree with author of the book. There is nothing wrong to do your research online. If I have a question, I need an answer right away. I don't have time to read a book or go to library. I need to get dress, get in a car, drive to library , find a book, read it and only after that I can find out when Edison invented the phonograph! Internet research is the most convenient tool: information available in different forms( picture, text, etc)+there are related topics surrounding your search, you always can get some extra info.
    N. Carr states that when you do online research, you do not have ability to retain information in your memory. I don't think it depends on source of information itself. In my opinion, the major factor is how interested subjuect of your research is.
    I enjoy reading books. However, I prefer to do online research.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with the idea that we may be loosing old ways of research but I feel like online search engines are also very beneficial. You probably would go get a book on something if it was just a random question you thought of during your day. But with internet and sites like google we can easily answer random little questions. These answers can then lead you to ask more questions and look further. They can also be simple and not need much more thought. Wondering what time zone Mongolia is in probably doesn't require you to read a whole book on the country. But searching the question on Google you not only will answer your question but could also come upon other information on the country and inform yourself about it. Books and the internet both are important tools for learning, the trick is knowing which is better for what.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I actually disagree with this. I think the giant database of knowledge that is Google/wikipedia/ect improves what we know. It makes it so much easier to find things out. Yes it can be used as a crutch sometimes but its not like you completely forget EVERYTHING you read, once you look something up you will know more about it then you did before.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Although the idea of reading a book to solve your questions is great... the problem is time! I mean if you need to know something NOW, are you really gonna spend 4 hrs reading a book when you can instantly access it online? There is too much to do and too little time. So just google it!

    ReplyDelete